法学家 ›› 2016, Vol. 0 ›› Issue (2): 96-108.

• 论文 • 上一篇    下一篇

财产权限制的行政补偿判断标准

杜仪方,法学博士,复旦大学法学院副教授。   

  • 出版日期:2016-04-15 发布日期:2016-04-21

Judgment Criterion for Administrative Recuperation in Property Right Limitation

Du Yifang, Ph.D. in Law, Associate Professor of Fudan University Law School.   

  • Online:2016-04-15 Published:2016-04-21

摘要: 现代社会中私有财产受到公权力限制的情况屡见不鲜。日本宪法和法律规定,国家为了公共利益有权限制财产权,并同时规定了补偿制度,但没有明确补偿的判断标准。理论界基于权利人、规制行为和财产为中心分别归纳出多种补偿判断标准,而司法判决则以财产权的损失作为是否补偿的出发点,并以财产权的性质判断是否存在特别牺牲。财产权限制行政补偿判断标准首先可以划分为限制标准(行为)与补偿标准(损失),其中对损失的界定又存在“特别”标准与“牺牲”标准,再进而对“牺牲”进行解释并在财产权限制的多发领域寻求以状况拘束性理论作为最终判断标准。以财产权限制补偿判断标准为契机,有必要以特别牺牲概念为核心重新审视行政补偿概念。

关键词: 财产权限制, 行政补偿, 特别牺牲, 状况拘束性

Abstract: he private property is restricted by public power in modern society.The constitution and law provided the limitation of property right and the loss compensation system without clear compensation standard.Theorists, based on the parties, behavior regulation and property for the center separately, summarize many kinds of compensation standard, while judgment regards the loss of property rights as the start point of compensation, and takes the nature of property rights as the standard of the special sacrifice.Property right limit compensation standard can be divided into limit standard(behavior)and compensation standard(losses). The definition of losses can be separated into“special”standard and“sacrifice”standard.Moreover, the property right limit compensation explains the“sacrifice”and seeks the state constraint theory as the final standard.In this case, it is the opportunity to explore the property right limit compensation standard, and reconstructs the administrative recuperation concept based on special sacrifice.

Key words: Property Limitation, Administrative Recuperation, Special Sacrifice, State Constraint