法学家 ›› 2023, Vol. 0 ›› Issue (1): 74-89.

• 专论 • 上一篇    下一篇

格劳秀斯、荷兰殖民帝国与国际法史书写的主体性问题

章永乐   

  • 出版日期:2023-01-15 发布日期:2023-01-10
  • 作者简介:章永乐,政治学博士,北京大学法学院长聘副教授。
  • 基金资助:
    本文系国家社会科学基金一般项目“国际体系与国际法视野下的中国宪法变革路径研究”(18BFX032)的阶段性成果。

Grotius,the Dutch Colonial Empire,and the Rediscovery of Subjectivity in the Writing of the History of International Law

ZHANG Yongle   

  • Online:2023-01-15 Published:2023-01-10
  • About author:Zhang Yongle, Ph.D. in Political Science, Associate Professor of Peking University Law School.

摘要: 自19世纪以来,格劳秀斯在西方学术界与舆论界获得了“国际法之父”乃至“和平主义者”的形象。然而,遵循“帝国与国际法”的学术路径进行语境化解读,可以发现格劳秀斯对“自然法”与“万民法”的书写具有强烈的荷兰国家利益本位色彩,并且随着荷兰殖民实践的推进而不断调整。19世纪以来格劳秀斯之形象的重塑,受到美国精英鼓吹、荷兰民族主义以及国际法职业化等多重因素的影响;在这些因素的影响下,通过对格劳秀斯文本“去语境化”的阅读,格劳秀斯与荷兰殖民主义之间的关联被忽略乃至抹去。在正面临“百年未有之大变局”的当下,中国学者有必要通过对国际法思想家思想文本与语境之间关系的深入探究,揭示国际法思想叙事得以形成的深层逻辑,从而增强独立自主的中国主体意识,积极推动当代国际法秩序朝着更为公正的方向演进。

关键词: 格劳秀斯, 国际法史, 万民法, 帝国理由, 国际法秩序

Abstract: Since the19th century, Grotius has gained the image of “father of international law” and even “pacifist” in Western academic and public opinion circles.However, following the approach of “Empire and International Law”, it can be found that Grotius' writing on “natural law” and “law of nations” self-consciously served the Dutch national interest, and was updated to match the evolving Dutch colonial practice of his time.The reshaping of Grotius' image since the 19th century was influenced by the participation of the US elites, Dutch nationalism, and the professionalization of international law.With the “de-contextualizing” method of reading, the historical connection between Grotius and Dutch colonialism has been ignored or even erased.Under the “great changes unseen in a century”, it is necessary to reveal the deep logic of the formation of the ideological narrative of international law through in-depth exploration of the relationship between the texts and contexts of international law thinkers, so as to enhance the independent consciousness of China's subjectivity and actively promote contemporary reform toward a more just international legal order.

Key words: Grotius, History of International Law, Law of Nations, Raison d'empire, International Legal Order